In the 21st century, "Just War Theory" is, in a word, irrelevant. Even if we were to stipulate, for the sake of argument, that, in theory, a war could be "just," the conditions at the present time make such a theory untenable in practice. The problem is now (and, in my view, has always been) the profit motive. Profit achieved by means of fair and equitable trade is one thing; profit achieved by armed robbery is quite another.
War is big business. Arguments about "just war" are nothing but "language on holiday" as Wittgenstein would say.
To say nothing of the "methods" of modern warfare (i.e. bombing of cities and villages, drone attacks, large scale urban warfare; all tactics which virtually guarantee enormous civilian casualties)
ReplyDelete